Existing Standards for Whole Grains
digg this
del.icio.usWhat exactly IS a whole grain food? What counts? Consumers wanting to get the recommended number of servings each day want to know. School foodservice directors being asked to "serve more whole grains" want to know. And manufacturers looking to label their products responsibly want to know.
The answer is fairly straightforward when you're dealing with 100% whole grains. A dish of brown rice or oatmeal is whole grain – no questions asked. As is a slice of bread made with no other grain but whole grain.
The answer isn't simple, however, when a product's ingredients include both whole grains and refined/enriched grains. In many cases, whether such a product is considered "whole grain" depends on which government agency or program, in which country, has a say in the answer. Our list below covers most known standards in the U.S. plus several in other lands; we welcome visitors to this website to alert us to other standards elsewhere.
| Where+When | Who+What | What qualifies as a whole grain food |
Other restrictions /notes |
| USA 1999 / 2003 |
FDA Whole Grain Health Claim |
At least 51% of the total weight must be WG | limits on fats and cholesterol |
|
USA and |
Whole Grains Council US WG Stamp Intl. WG Stamp |
At least 8g WG per serving (Basic Stamp) |
none |
| USA Oct. 2005 |
USDA / FSIS Interim Policy Guidance |
At least 8g WG per serving At least 51% of the grain is whole grain |
none |
| USA Aug. 2006 |
Whole Grains Council WG Stamp FSIS |
At least 8g WG per serving and at least 51% of the grain is whole grain (Basic Stamp) At least 16g WG per serving and all the grain is whole grain (100% Stamp) |
(for use on foods containing meat and poultry and therefore under the jurisdiction of USDA FSIS) |
| USA Apr. 2007 |
IOM report on Nutrition Standards for Foods in Schools |
Requires foods to be (or contain a serving of) fruits, vegetables or whole grains but does not clearly define "serving." | Limits on fat, sugar, calories and sodium. |
| UK Nov. 2007 |
IGD UK Whole Grain Guidance Report |
For packaged foods wishing to communicate the presence of whole grain, for example, by stating ‘contains whole grains’ or ‘with whole grains’ on pack and in brand communications, the IGD Working Group recommend that foods should contain a minimum level of 8g whole grain per serving (based on final batch load proportions). | Foods calling attention to their whole grain content will need to make a Quantitative Ingredient Declaration (QUID). |
| Canada Dec. 2007 |
Whole Grains Council WG Stamp Canada |
At least 8g WG per serving (Basic Stamp) At least 16g WG per serving and all the ingredients are whole grain (100% Stamp in Canada) |
none |
| USA Dec. 2007 (final rule expected Feb. 2011) |
USDA / FNS WIC interim rules |
In general, WG must be the first ingredient and foods must qualify for the FDA whole grain health claim. | Only certain grain products qualify; no added sugar, salt, or oil allowed in rice, barley, bulgur or oatmeal; sugar restriction and iron requirement for breakfast cereals. |
| Denmark 2007, 2008 |
DTU (Danish National Food Institute) Fuldkorn (Whole grain) report |
Calculated on dry matter, the whole grains shall be the specified percent or more of the total grains, for each category: 100% for flour, grains, rice 50% for bread (AND 30% of total weight) 60% for crispbread, breakfast cereal, pasta |
Only the foods listed here can be called whole grain – so no whole grain cookies, cakes, waffles, etc.! |
| USA 2008 update |
USDA / FNS Healthier US School Challenge |
For the majority of whole grain foods, WG must be the first ingredient – or the weight of all whole grains totaled together must be more than the weight of any other ingredient. Some products qualify if the weight of all whole grains, totalled, is more than the weight of any other grain ingredient. | Must qualify as a Grain/Bread serving in the Food Buying Guide for Child Nutrition Programs (minimum of 14.75g of grain, in most cases) |
| Sweden – 1989 Denmark – 2009 Norway – 2009 |
Livsmedelsverket Natl. Food Admin. Keyhole Symbol |
Calculated on dry matter, the whole grains shall be the specified percent or more of the total grains, for each category: 100% for flour, meal, grains 50% for crispbread, porridge, pasta (unfilled) 25% for bread, sandwiches, wraps 15% for pizzas, pierogis, other savory pies |
Only the categories listed here are eligible. Limits on fats, sugars and sodium; minimum of fiber in some categories. See details. |
| USA Oct. 2009 |
IOM School Meals: Building Blocks for Healthy Children report |
Calls for schools to serve “whole grain-rich” foods; to qualify, a food must meet ONE of the following: a. contain at least 8 grams of whole grain content per serving OR b. qualify for the FDA whole grain health claim (51% whole grain by weight) OR c. have a whole grain as the first ingredient by weight for non-mixed dishes (e.g., breads, cereals) or as the first grain ingredient by weight for mixed dishes (e.g., pizza, corn dogs) |
Must qualify as a Grain/Bread serving in the Food Buying Guide for Child Nutrition Programs (minimum of 14.75g of grain, in most cases) Note: The report recommends raising the standard to more than 8g as time goes on. |
| Germany | Foods must have a certain baker’s percent of whole grain to use the name whole grain: 90% whole grain for wheat and rye bread 100% whole grain for pasta |
||
| Netherlands | NBC Dutch Bakery Centre |
Breads can only legally be called whole grain if 100% of the grain is whole grain. There’s no law for other foods, but common practice is to “use the 50% rule” and call products whole grain if at least half of the grain in a product is whole grain. | Terms such as 20%, 30% , 50% or 80% wholegrain on packaging are not used (and for bread legally not allowed). |
| Australia August 2009 |
Go Grains | There is no official government regulation on the definition of a wholegrain food, but Go Grains encourages manufacturers to make whole grain claims only if the food has at least 10% wholegrain content or 4.8g wholegrains “per serve.” |
Here are some definitions that may also be useful to understand:
| Country | Term |
Meaning |
Source |
| USA | 100% Whole Grain | All the grain is whole grain. | Feb 2007 Draft Guidance, FDA |
| Canada | 100% Whole Grain | All the ingredients are whole grain. |
